Most Useless NA in original revised version

[General Norde]

Here's an interesting poll, haven't seen it elsewhere although with all these subjects, I might have missed it.

What's the most useless NA in the original revised edition?

1- Salvage : Get a free tank if you survive a german attack in which the German lost a tank in a red territory. (Does this ever happen???)

2- Dive-bombers (The historical non-sense of dive bombers concentrating their strikes on industries) : Is it really worth risking a fighter on a flak gun for an average 2IPC bombing ? Maybe it is statisticly but it keeps your ultra-useful fighters occupied while they could be used in much more destructive missions. By the way, dive bombers gives your fighters a d3 SBR abiility

3- Mid-East Oil : Any fighter landing in trans-jordan/persia/Egypt in a non combat move gets to move again that turn.

4- Kaiten torpedoes : Lose a 8 IPC sub to make a +1 first shot while defending next to a yellow territory. (I'd rather keep my sub for the fight as he can take losses and if the other guy has a battleship, it stinks...)

5- Kamikazes : Scrap your 10 IPC fighters for a first shot on a sea attack... at least, it doesn't have to land back.

6- Fast Carrier : Might be good in a very specific situation in which your fleets are very far away from the homeland... but at that point, you are likely winning the game...

[AllWeNeedIsLove.]

well they are all useless. well kamikazes are not, but the rest are not even worth having in the game. this just makes me realize how good and even enhanced n/as are

[AAGeneral]

I agree with AWNIL. Except Kamikazes, the rest are useless.

[DocD]

Salvage is pretty bad...but I wish I had voted for M-E oil. One of my first post was about how useless this one was!

And not because you won't want a fighter to land in India eventually, but because it had nothing to do with OIL!!!

This should have been a huge NA for the Allies (like it was historically), but came off totally useless.

As far as LDB...hey I didn't mind them....I used them a few times to good effect.

[Beast1313131]

I liked the Kamikazes but found the rest fairly useless, but i voted against Kaiten Torpedoes.

[PaschatKing]

Kamikazes are weak, but not useless - it could be devastating. French Res. is weak, but not useless. (yes i know its not on the list). Kaiten is ****. U waste a sub and still no guarantee of a kill - if you could nominate a target with each and then need a '3', that would ease the pain. Aim at those TRNs or ACs.

[PrisonerOfWar]

I voted Salvage.

The attacker usually never attacks if they know they will lose, so Russia never gets their free tank. To throw away tanks into a losing battle as the attacker would be the stupidest possible move ever.

[PaschatKing]

Salvage is indeed lame.